Lawyers: if the ECHR will have to rely on the law, "RUSAL" will win the case

"RUSAL" will win the case in the European court of human rights against the nationalization of the Zaporozhye aluminum combine (ZALK), If the court in its own decision will be based on law, not politics, according to polled Last news lawyers.

"The prospects of winning a lawsuit of "RUSAL" good, because Ukraine did not come out from under the jurisdiction of the ECHR. If nationalization occurred for political reasons, because (President of "RUSAL" Oleg) Deripaska is a citizen of Russia, then, without doubt, "RUSAL" this lawsuit will win, " - said the expert on international law Vsevolod Miller.

However, With the enforcement of the court decision have the opportunity to cause problems, He said.

"by and large, the decisions of the ECtHR have the opportunity not to be fulfilled. On the reverse side, the Ukrainians now all these Europeans that they have the opportunity to voluntarily comply, " says Miller.

lawyer Dmitry agranovskii has also welcomed the Prospects of a complaint of " RUSAL ".

"From a legal Perspective good, If RUSAL specifies as the source of the publication 1 of Protocol 1 to the European Convention - protection of property." In my opinion, in this case, the complaint must recognize acceptable, " said the defending Player.

Agranovski? reported that "RUSAL" have the opportunity to play two factors - politics and time.

"in may intervene policy, and we are in the last period of time see that the activities of the European court of human rights policy has an impact, then Russian organizations against Ukraine to win will be very difficult," - said the agranovskii.

He also recalled that the ECtHR considers complaints and the decisions on them over the years and in this case, in the opinion of counsel, the court will not take the most hurry.

"How much time it will consider, it is unclear at the ECHR currently there is no incentive to speed up this procedure, and the case could be reviewed for so long that policy will have time to come to a common opinion about yourself and "RUSAL" and among them ", - believes agranovski?.


sections: Politics