Tatyana Firsova. Dialogue of Ministers of foreign Affairs of the countries " channel four ", which took place yesterday in Paris, were contradictory and full of inconsistencies between representatives of Russia and Ukraine, said the official representative of the German foreign Ministry Martin Schaefer. "The meeting lasted at least 4 hours, All four Ministers discussed the Ukrainian conflict and the current state of Affairs. The discussion was controversial, noted the existing divergence of views between Kiev and the capital of Russia in how specifically to implement the Minsk consensus, " said Schaefer correspondents in Berlin. anyway, despite this, All four Ministers of foreign Affairs - Germany, France, Russia and Ukraine " confirmed their commitment to the Minsk ", for example, discussed a number of specific Topics. "The four Ministers yesterday again expressed commitment to" Minsk ", real projects, which were discussed is an attempt , for example, in settlements Shirokino