Scientists from the Chinese University of Hong Kong, Tszewei Liu and Ji-Kang Chen, analyzed data from 1,329 Taiwanese schoolchildren aged 10-17 (average age 15, roughly half girls). Almost four fifths of the participants (78%) grew up in single-parent families. All of them lived in poverty: two thirds of the families received state assistance, and the rest were recognized as needy by the nonprofit organization Taiwan Fund for Children and Families. The results were published in the journal Behavioral Sciences & the Law.

Material deprivation is a lack of basic resources: food, clothing, electricity, medical care or money for everyday needs. The scientists examined how it is linked to psychological stress and substance use, and what role relationships with family, peers and teachers play in this. The hypothesis was that deprivation worsens relationships, and poor relationships in turn increase the risk of stress and use.

The data were collected in 2013-2014 using questionnaires. Material deprivation was assessed using 17 yes/no questions (for example, "I skip breakfast or lunch to save money"). The quality of relationships with family was measured using an adapted scale of family adaptation and cohesion, with peers using three items, and with teachers using six. Psychological stress was identified using a brief symptom scale (low mood, tension, sleep problems over the past week). Substance use was asked about separately: whether the teenager had smoked cigarettes, drunk alcohol or chewed betel - areca palm seeds, which are used in Asia as a stimulant; chewing them increases the risk of oral cancer.

It turned out that the more pronounced the material deprivation, the slightly worse the relationships with peers, only slightly worse with family and teachers, and the higher the psychological stress. At the same time, no direct link was found between deprivation and substance use. Teenagers who used such substances more often had somewhat worse relationships with family and teachers (but not with peers) and slightly higher stress.

The researchers then built a statistical model to test whether relationships act as a mediator - that is, whether they explain the link between deprivation and the outcomes. For stress, the model confirmed the path through family: more deprivation - worse family relationships - more stress. Relationships with peers and teachers did not play this role, and the direct link between deprivation and stress remained. For substance use, the model pointed to all three types of relationships, but the directions turned out to be different: good relationships with family were linked to less use, with teachers there was a similar but weaker and borderline tendency, and good relationships with peers were linked to more use, which the authors explain by possible peer influence. All these indirect links were very weak.

The path through family relationships worked for both girls and boys, and for middle and high school students. The authors suggest that support programs for poor teenagers could combine financial assistance with strengthening family relationships.

It is important to understand the limitations. The sample consisted only of teenagers from poor families, so the spread of deprivation indicators was small - this could have weakened the links. The study design does not allow conclusions about cause-and-effect relationships: all the associations discussed are statistical correlations that by themselves do not prove that one phenomenon causes another. In addition, the data are based on self-reports: teenagers could have exaggerated hardships or concealed use. Finally, more than ten years have passed since the data were collected, and the circumstances of poor families' lives could have changed.

Source: PsyPost