Scientists from the Nencki Institute of Experimental Biology of the Polish Academy of Sciences have found that in children who later develop dyslexia, already in kindergarten, before formal reading instruction begins, there is weaker brain adaptation to repeated written words. At the same time, their reactions to faces, houses and objects are the same as those of their peers. The results of the study were published in the journal Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience.
Dyslexia is a learning disorder in which a person experiences persistent difficulties with accurate and fluent reading, despite normal intelligence and adequate instruction. One hypothesis links dyslexia to impaired neural adaptation, a phenomenon in which brain cells respond more weakly to a repeated stimulus than to a new one. It is thought that this reflects the efficiency of recognizing familiar images.
Previously, in a 2016 study, adults with dyslexia were found to have weakened adaptation to repeated words, faces and objects. However, all participants in the earlier studies could already read, so it was impossible to determine whether reduced adaptation precedes reading difficulties or is a consequence of them.
The new study involved 47 children who were scanned twice: in kindergarten (mean age 6.6-6.8 years) and in third grade (9.7-9.9 years). Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) was used, a method that tracks changes in blood flow associated with brain activity. The children were shown sequences of six images: Polish nouns, unfamiliar symbols, faces, houses and objects. In some series all the pictures were different, in others the same stimulus was repeated six times. The difference in activity was considered an indicator of neural adaptation.
By third grade, 16 children had been diagnosed with dyslexia. They were compared with 16 peers without reading problems, matched by age and initial reading skills in kindergarten. In kindergarten, the groups did not differ in IQ, phonological perception (the ability to distinguish speech sounds), rapid naming, letter knowledge and visual attention. In third grade, typically reading children read more than twice as fast: 85.6 words per minute versus 39.2 in children with dyslexia.
It turned out that in the left ventral occipitotemporal cortex, an area associated with visual word recognition, adaptation to written words was weaker in future dyslexics than in typical readers. This gap was present already in kindergarten and persisted in third grade. At the same time, adaptation to faces, houses and objects did not differ between the groups. The weakened adaptation to words was localized in the anterior part of this area of the left hemisphere.
The authors emphasize that since the difference in adaptation to words was found before reading instruction began, it is unlikely to be explained solely by the fact that children with dyslexia read less. However, the study is observational, and it does not prove a causal relationship. In addition, the group comparison was small (16 people each), and the analysis of regions of interest was exploratory rather than preregistered. Whole-brain differences and associations with reading skills after correction for multiple comparisons were statistically insignificant. The scientists conclude that early subtle differences in the brain's tuning to printed text may contribute to reading difficulties, but larger studies with frequent scanning are needed to confirm this.