An international group of researchers led by Maria Vittoria Messina, together with Asia Saturnino and endocrinologist Paolo Pozzilli from the Fondazione Policlinico Universitario Campus Bio-Medico clinic in Rome, set out to determine how much the ideals of female beauty differed across eras. To do this, they analyzed 11 paintings by Impressionists depicting nude female figures, including works by Edgar Degas, Pierre-Auguste Renoir and Paul Cezanne. The results were published in the International Journal of Obesity.
To estimate the sizes of the painted women, the scientists used body mass index (BMI), a standard medical measure calculated by dividing a person's weight in kilograms by the square of their height in meters. By this measure, the World Health Organization classifies people into categories of normal weight, overweight or obesity.
Exact measurements cannot be obtained from paintings, so the researchers used the digital program BMI Visualizer, which creates three-dimensional body models from an image. Artificial intelligence checked how well the models matched the proportions on the canvas and adjusted the parameters until the digital figure matched the painted one. The researchers assumed the same height for all the women: 154.3 centimeters. This number was taken from 19th-century historical records on the average height of female prisoners.
The estimated weight of the depicted women ranged from 71.0 to 78.0 kilograms. The average BMI was 31.0. The lowest figure in the sample was 29.8, and the highest was 32.8. According to current WHO criteria, a BMI of 18.5 to 24.9 is considered normal. Thus, the figures that the Impressionists regarded as the embodiment of beauty would today be classified by physicians as overweight or obesity.
However, BMI does not directly reflect health status: it does not take into account the ratio of muscle to fat, heredity or metabolism. In some medical situations, for example with severe infections, extra weight may even play a protective role. The authors emphasize that their calculation is a statistical estimate, not proof that the depicted women were unhealthy.
The researchers also note that art does not always reflect reality. In 19th-century Europe, famine and poverty were rampant, and real women were on the whole much slimmer than in the paintings. The fuller figures in the paintings remained an ideal unattainable for most. Today the situation is the opposite: fashion and social media push toward excessive thinness, and the pursuit of it sometimes leads to eating disorders. The scientists also mention the growing illegal use of semaglutide, a drug originally developed to treat diabetes, for rapid weight loss.
According to the authors, both historical paintings and modern glossy images are more cultural constructs than a reflection of the health of a nation. They call for seeking a balance between aesthetics and physical well-being, without falling into extremes on either side.