A new study involving children aged 7-9 found that those who regularly play a musical instrument on average show higher results on tests of mental ability and school achievement than their peers without musical training. The work was published in the journal Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience.
Childhood is an important period of brain development, when external activities can influence its structure and function. Scientists have long been interested in whether music training helps not only to master rhythms and melodies but also to develop so-called executive functions (the ability to plan, switch, and control oneself), as well as reading and speech. Some data also point to changes in connections between brain regions.
The authors analyzed data from the FITKids2 study - a physical activity program for children from east-central Illinois (USA). Only information collected before the start of classes was used; there was no musical intervention within the project. Of 175 children with complete data, 38 regularly played an instrument (at least 30 minutes per week according to parents), and 137 did not. Among the musical children, pianists were most common (29), followed by string instrument players.
The children underwent a battery of tests, including the Woodcock-Johnson scale (assesses general intelligence and individual abilities), the Operation Span task (working memory - the ability to hold information and operate on it) and the Kaufman test (achievement in mathematics, reading, writing). For comparison, each child with musical training was matched with a pair without it of the same age, sex and socioeconomic status. In the end, 38 children in each group were analyzed, and for MRI - 25 in each.
Results: the "musical" children outperformed their peers on a number of measures - general intelligence, brief intellectual ability, spatial relations, verbal comprehension, visual-auditory learning and working memory. There were no differences in thinking efficiency and planning. They also performed better on all composite achievement scales (reading, mathematics, written language) and most individual subtests.
Brain scanning revealed a possible difference in the right arcuate fasciculus - a bundle of nerve fibers connecting the motor and auditory areas. The musicians had a higher "mode of anisotropy" measure (reflects how much the fibers run in one direction rather than crossing). However, after correction for multiple comparisons, the difference ceased to be statistically significant, and no differences were found in the left hemisphere or in other white matter parameters.
The authors conclude: the results indicate the value of playing an instrument during a period of rapid brain and thinking development. But they emphasize: the study design does not allow speaking of a causal relationship. It is possible that playing children simply receive more family enrichment and are involved in additional activities. In addition, musical training was assessed from parents' words, without taking into account intensity and skill, and matching with pairs led to the exclusion of most children without music; the MRI data were low-resolution and only from 50 children.