When the Universe was less than 700 million years old, the black hole powering quasar J0313-1806 already weighed about 3 billion solar masses. How it grew so fast has been debated by astrophysicists for about twenty years.

The problem is the speed limit. A black hole grows by swallowing gas, but the infalling matter heats up and glows, and the radiation pushes on gas not yet swallowed. At the Eddington limit, light pressure balances gravity, and the infall rate stops increasing. If about 10% of the infalling mass turns into radiation, the hole's mass increases by roughly a factor of 2.7 every 45 million years.

A seed of a hundred solar masses would need about 770 million years to grow to 3 billion. Allowing time for stars to form, the Universe had less than 600 million years left.

Two solutions are usually proposed: start with a heavy seed of at least 10 thousand solar masses, or exceed the Eddington limit. Both have caveats: direct collapse requires rare conditions, and prolonged super-Eddington growth is unproven.

In a paper published in Astronomy & Astrophysics, Kastytis Zubovas and Matas Tartenas of the Center for Physical and Technological Sciences in Vilnius tested a third idea - chaotic accretion, that is, disordered gas infall. It requires neither a heavy seed nor a violation of the limit.

In the model, gas falls in from random directions. Each stream forms a small disk tilted at a random angle to the hole's spin axis, feeds it briefly, and is replaced by another. Some episodes spin the hole up, others slow it down. Slowing is rarer but more effective, so the spin stays slow.

A slowly rotating hole converts about 6-7.5% of the accreted mass into light instead of 10%. This shortens the characteristic growth time from 45 to about 27-32 million years, and the timescale for J0313-1806 from 770 to 550 million years.

The authors compared the predictions with mass estimates of known supermassive black holes at redshifts above seven (redshift is a measure of an object's distance and age). The most reliable estimates, including J0313-1806, are explained by a seed of about 100 solar masses or less that formed 100 million years after the Big Bang and grew with a characteristic time of about 32 million years. This requires almost continuous feeding: at least 85% of the time at the Eddington limit, or all the time at 85% of it.

The scenario works, but does not prove the alternatives wrong. It does not explain a number of mass estimates obtained by methods with many assumptions about the gas flow. For example, for the galaxy GN-z11 the reliable estimate is about seven times lower than the less reliable one. For several more distant holes there are no reliable masses - they will become targets for future observations.

The explanations can be distinguished by spin: chaotic accretion predicts slow rotation in the most massive early holes, while prolonged super-Eddington growth predicts fast rotation. Spin is measured from the shape of X-ray lines, but current data are ambiguous. The planned NewAthena observatory would be suitable, but its launch is expected no earlier than 2037.

According to the model, the maximum black hole mass should rise rapidly up to redshift 7.5 and then nearly level off. The data hint at this, but cover too small a volume. Wide surveys such as Euclid and Roman will help. A reliably measured black hole of more than a billion solar masses at redshift 9.1 or higher would refute the model.

The authors' conclusion is modest: ordinary stellar-mass seeds growing near the Eddington limit with slow rotation can explain the earliest known supermassive black holes without massive seeds or super-Eddington growth. Next-generation telescopes will test this.

Source: Phys.org