Speculation around Anthropic's stock market valuation has highlighted one of the riskiest bets in finance - the attempt to put a price on the future of artificial intelligence. A few days before its initial public offering (IPO - the first sale of a company's shares on an exchange), the developer of the Claude AI agent said it expects a capitalization of up to $1.4 trillion. That figure would place the young company among the largest stock market debuts in history, although it falls short of the $2 trillion mentioned in some estimates just a few weeks earlier.
Since then, concern about the development and profitability of AI has gripped the market. OpenAI, a competitor planning an IPO in 2027, is valued at $1.025 trillion on the private market, US media report.
There are two main ways to value a company, Michelle Lowry, a professor of finance at Drexel University, said. The first is to estimate how much money the company will bring in over the coming years. Money expected in the distant future is worth less than today's money, especially when it is uncertain, so future amounts are discounted to present value. The second method compares the company with similar public firms. If those are valued at, say, five times annual revenue, the same multiple is applied to the company being valued.
Both methods are well known, but "in Anthropic's case both approaches are quite difficult," Lowry told AFP. Like most AI companies, Anthropic is still burning money and has not found a path to profitability, which makes forecasting its future cash flows difficult. It also has few public comparables. The closest is SpaceX, which made a record debut on Wall Street in June with a valuation of $1.77 trillion. But that comparison is imperfect, since the company led by Elon Musk combines a social network, space operations and an AI lab. SpaceX also relies on Musk's star status among retail investors.
So how was the $1.4 trillion figure set? "There is some bargaining process" between companies seeking an IPO and institutional investors, said Minmo Gahng, an assistant professor of finance at Cornell University. Investment banks act as intermediaries between the parties, and this process can be very long. A company's valuation is its share price multiplied by the number of shares outstanding. A company going public wants the price to be as high as possible, since the amount of capital raised depends on it. But it also needs to leave enough room to attract buyers, since weak demand would crush the shares. Investors, in turn, want to be sure they can later sell their stakes at a profit, and hope for a "pop" - a sharp rise in the share price on the first day of trading.
On Friday, in a conversation with JPMorgan Chase chief Jamie Dimon, Anthropic co-founder and CEO Dario Amodei, discussing the IPO, referred to the company's motto: "promise less, do more." He also said the company is going public mainly because it needs funding. Anthropic plans to raise a total of $90 billion, which it intends to direct toward developing advanced AI.
Jay Ritter, an IPO specialist at the University of Florida, said investors accept such valuations because several companies, such as Amazon, Alphabet and Nvidia, have shown that "you can make $100 billion a year or more in profit, and competition will not eat it away." But there is "no guarantee" that Anthropic will achieve the same, he warned. "There is a possible case that in 10 years Anthropic will be left behind, and no one will use advanced large language models, because open models will turn out to be good enough and cheap."
Anthropic's growth is already showing signs of slowing, and 90 pages of its IPO prospectus are devoted to the risks the company's future - and even humanity's - may face depending on the direction AI development takes.