Men who frequently reappraise unpleasant situations in everyday life cope better with mild negative emotions when their baseline cortisol - the stress hormone - is elevated. That is the conclusion of researchers from Lithuania who published their work in the journal Psychoneuroendocrinology. Testosterone - the main male sex hormone - on its own or together with cortisol did not show a consistent link with emotional control.

The study concerns cognitive reappraisal - a conscious strategy in which a person mentally changes the meaning of an unpleasant scene so that it seems less threatening. For example, on seeing a crying child, one can imagine that nothing terrible has happened and that the parents are already hurrying to comfort him. The ability to do this is linked to psychological well-being, while difficulties with emotion regulation occur in many mental disorders.

The study involved men from Lithuania aged 20 to 36. Two were excluded because of diagnosed depression or schizotypal disorder, and one more as a statistical outlier. The scientists measured baseline cortisol and testosterone from saliva samples, then asked participants to look at photographs of people - neutral ones, ones with mild negative scenes and ones with severe injuries. In half of the cases the men simply reacted naturally; in the other half they actively reappraised what they saw.

The ability to reappraise the situation worked on its own: during active reappraisal, participants rated the images as less unpleasant. However, neither cortisol, nor testosterone, nor their combination predicted the success of reappraisal across the whole group. The link appeared only in those who often use this strategy in ordinary life, and only on photographs with mild negative scenes: the higher the baseline cortisol, the fewer unpleasant feelings the men experienced during reappraisal. The effect turned out to be small - slightly above the minimum the sample allowed to detect.

"Although the effect was small, it is well consistent with the literature on the positive influence of cortisol on emotion regulation," PsyPost quoted lead author Erikas Ilkevicius of Vilnius University as saying. He stressed that hormones cannot be studied in isolation from context: the result is influenced by the environment, other hormones and a person's psychological characteristics.

No consistent associations were found with testosterone in any analysis. According to Ilkevicius, this is rather good news: even men with elevated testosterone are capable of successfully reappraising situations and managing emotions. The scientist also called for "rehabilitating" both hormones: chronically elevated cortisol is harmful, but an optimal baseline level and an adequate response to stress are important for the health of body and mind, and testosterone is not reducible to aggression.

An important limitation: the study is cross-sectional, hormones were not changed experimentally, so a causal relationship cannot be established. It is quite possible that men who are better at reappraisal initially have slightly higher cortisol. In addition, the sample included only healthy young men from Lithuania, so the results cannot be transferred to women, older people or patients with disorders. The authors also note that the questionnaire on habitual reappraisal showed moderate internal consistency, and the emotion ratings were self-reported.

Source: PsyPost