Researchers surveyed adults from Canada, the US and Japan to find out whether personality traits are linked to the number of biological children. The results were published in the journal Culture and Evolution. It turned out that people with high extraversion (sociability and activity), agreeableness (willingness to cooperate) and low neuroticism (a tendency toward anxiety and mood swings) have slightly more children on average. However, the link is weak, and other factors make the main contribution to family size.

The study was led by Marianne L. Fisher, a professor of psychology at Saint Mary's University in Halifax (Canada). She and her colleagues relied on the "Big Five" model - five broad personality dimensions: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism. Participants completed a brief 10-item questionnaire and reported the number of biological children. Data were collected in February-March 2022 via an online panel; each country had an equal number of men and women aged 20 and older, divided into five age groups.

First, demographic characteristics - marriage, sex, age and country - explained about 21 percent of the variance in the number of children. Married people, women, older people and those in heterosexual marriages had more children. The US and Canada had more children than Japan, which corresponds to differences in birth rates: 12.2 births per 1,000 people in the US, 10 in Canada and 6.9 in Japan.

Adding personality traits statistically improved the model, but the total explained share remained about 21 percent. This means that, on top of demographics, personality adds little. In the pooled sample, extraversion and agreeableness were associated with slightly more children, and neuroticism with slightly fewer. The links with conscientiousness and openness were statistically insignificant.

Moreover, the nature of these links differed by country: after adjustment for marital status and sex, all five traits correlated differently with the number of children depending on place of residence. Average personality profiles in Canada and the US were similar, while Japan differed noticeably.

The authors emphasize that this is a correlational study, meaning it records a statistical association but does not prove causation. It cannot be said that character traits directly lead to having children. In addition, the data were collected at a single point in time, so it is impossible to determine whether personality influences parenting or vice versa. A short 10-item questionnaire was used, and all responses were self-reports, which may introduce bias. Unplanned pregnancies, fertility problems and a deliberate decision not to have children were not taken into account.

"The effects are small but important," Fisher said. "I would not advise treating personality as a prediction of family size for a specific person until further research is conducted." She also noted that sex differences in Canada, a country with a high gender-equality ranking, turned out to be unexpected: Canadian men surpassed women in extraversion, agreeableness and conscientiousness, while women surpassed them only in neuroticism.

Source: PsyPost