Young people with symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) or with childhood trauma more often report dangerous driving. A new study published in the journal Psychological Reports found that childhood trauma does not amplify the risks associated with ADHD. The two factors act independently.
Road crashes are one of the leading causes of death among young people in the United States. Drivers aged 15-29 are especially vulnerable. Psychologists are looking for factors that could help reduce the number of crashes.
ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity. Inattention is difficulty sustaining focus. Hyperactivity and impulsivity are excessive activity and hasty actions without regard for consequences.
Drivers with ADHD more often receive fines, lose their licenses and are involved in crashes. But the risk is not uniform: according to one survey, 60% of drivers with ADHD had not had even minor crashes in a year. That means there are other factors.
Researchers led by Adam K. Haag of Saint Louis University studied adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) - stressful or traumatic events before age 18: abuse, parental divorce, substance abuse in the family.
Children with ADHD more often have more ACEs. ADHD symptoms can provoke stricter punishment, and trauma can worsen symptoms. Both factors impair executive functions - the skills that help restrain impulses and shift attention.
The scientists tested the vulnerability hypothesis: whether a large number of ACEs amplifies dangerous driving associated with ADHD. They surveyed 263 drivers aged 18-29. The questionnaires assessed ADHD symptoms, childhood trauma and two types of dangerous driving: risky (aggression, speeding, ignoring rules) and distracted (phone use behind the wheel).
Results: higher overall ADHD scores were associated with the frequency of both types of dangerous driving. A greater number of ACEs was associated only with risky driving, but not with distracted driving. The interaction of the factors was statistically non-significant: trauma did not amplify the effect of ADHD. The authors speak of equifinality - different factors independently lead to the same outcome.
In a separate analysis of ADHD components, inattention predicted only risky driving, while hyperactivity and impulsivity predicted both types. In the combined model, only hyperactivity and impulsivity reliably predicted risky driving. It may be these traits that make driving most dangerous.
Why is trauma associated with aggressive driving but not with phone use? People with ACEs more often seek thrills - new and intense experiences. Speeding provides an adrenaline rush, while texting does not.
Limitations: self-report data at a single point in time, which does not prove causality. Because of an error in the survey, not all standard ACE questions were used, which may have underestimated the frequency of trauma. Longitudinal observations and objective data - fines, insurance reports - are needed.
The study "Adverse Childhood Experiences as a Moderator of Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder and Risky and Distracted Driving" was conducted by Adam K. Haag, Annie A. Garner, Terry L. Weaver, Phillip D. Ruppert and Christopher J. Schmanck.