Many schoolchildren with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) - a condition in which a child has difficulty concentrating for long periods, controlling impulses and sitting still calmly - receive special accommodations at school. These may include extra time on a test, frequent short breaks, permission to stand at the desk or noise-blocking headphones. However, a clinical trial published in the journal JAMA Pediatrics showed that such measures on their own improve neither behavior nor academic performance.
The study was conducted by a team led by Gregory A. Fabiano, a professor of psychology at the University of Florida (USA). The trial involved 280 children diagnosed with ADHD, from kindergarten through sixth grade. It took place over four summer seasons from 2022 to 2025 in two regions of the United States - the Southeast and the Northeast. The children attended a structured summer program in which each child took turns going through all the experimental conditions. This method is called crossover - it allows each participant to be compared with themselves under different conditions.
First, all the children studied in a regular classroom where the teacher only occasionally praised them and kept a quiet tally of rule violations. Then the conditions changed: in one variant, enhanced behavioral support was introduced - clear rules, frequent specific praise, individual behavior diaries and rewards for completing them. In parallel, during separate weeks the children received either a placebo (an empty capsule with no medication) or an extended-release stimulant, methylphenidate, at a moderate dose - on average about 19 mg. Neither the children nor the staff knew what was being given in each week (a double-blind condition).
Four common accommodations were tested in random order by day: extended time on tasks, frequent breaks, standing desks and workstations with headphones and partitions. The results were disappointing: none of them statistically significantly reduced the number of rule violations or improved quiz scores. Moreover, extra time and "quiet" places even reduced productivity - the number of correctly solved problems per minute fell by 11% and 4%, respectively. Frequent breaks and standing desks produced a small reduction, but it was not statistically significant.
Behavioral support and medication, however, did work. In a regular classroom without accommodations, children on average violated the rules 5.74 times per hour during independent work. With the enhanced behavioral program, that number fell to 3.96; with the stimulant, to 2.75; and with both combined, to 1.27. Overall, behavioral support reduced the expected number of violations by 37%, and the medication by 61% compared with placebo. Methylphenidate also increased task completion speed by 22% and improved quiz results by an average of 3.9 percentage points (from about 66% to 70%).
The authors emphasize that the study was conducted in a summer camp with highly qualified staff, not in a regular school over the course of a year, so the results require verification in real-world conditions. In addition, Fabiano disclosed a financial interest: he receives royalties from Guilford Press, which publishes his guide on behavior diaries. Nevertheless, the conclusion is clear: schools may need to focus on active behavioral strategies rather than passive accommodations. "Even if accommodations don't work, that doesn't mean children can't be helped," Fabiano says. "It just means the help has to be different."