In ordinary metals, electrons behave as particles that from time to time collide with crystal defects or its vibrations. However, in materials with strong interaction between electrons, for example in superconductors based on copper oxide (cuprates), this picture breaks down. In the so-called "strange metals," electrical resistance grows strictly linearly with temperature over a very wide range. Electrons lose momentum at the maximum rate that quantum mechanics allows - this limit is called the Planckian limit. What exactly causes such behavior has so far remained an open question.

In a study published in the journal Nature Physics, a group led by Simona Fratini of the Institut Neel (CNRS / Universite Grenoble-Alpes), together with Arnaud Ralko (Institut Neel), Ivan Duchemin (CEA, Grenoble) and Sergio Ciuchi (University of L'Aquila), proposed a simple explanation. According to their conclusions, the Planckian behavior is connected not with how electrons collide, but with the quantum nature of their response to an electric field.

The calculations used the t-J model - the standard description of strongly interacting electrons in copper oxide planes. Advanced numerical methods made it possible to calculate the electrical properties accurately down to temperatures corresponding to approximately 40 kelvin in real cuprates. These are record-low temperatures for such calculations - below the effective temperatures achievable in cold-atom simulators, and previously they were inaccessible.

The results reproduce the main features of strange metals observed in experiments. Resistance grows linearly with temperature precisely at the Planckian rate. Such behavior arises over a wide range of charge concentrations when magnetic order is suppressed, and does not require fine-tuning of a "quantum critical point." Conductivity simply scales with the number of mobile charges: each of them moves independently in a fluctuating magnetic background. In addition, the calculations explain why optical absorption in cuprates is not described by the classical Drude model.

The key observation concerns the response of the material at different frequencies and in time. In such "bad metals," electrons lose coherence after each hop. The current fluctuations in this case do not contain a Planckian time scale. It appears only through a fundamental quantum-statistical factor linking current fluctuations to the measured conductivity - the so-called quantum detailed balance.

"This result is the culmination of many years of work on how charges move in bad metals. It is gratifying to see that one ingredient - the quantum nature of the electron response - can explain so many mysterious observations," Ciuchi said, according to a press release.

The authors call their conclusion a call for a paradigm shift. In bad metals, Planckian behavior is not a property of charge-carrier scattering, but a consequence of the quantum-statistical nature of their response to an electric field. "We are now working on an experimental test of this scenario, and news will appear very soon," Fratini says.

Source: Phys.org