A new study in the journal Psychology of Music shows that repeated listening to an unfamiliar pop song strengthens the feeling that its chorus is catchy and easy to remember, while a simultaneous verbal memory load weakens this effect. The work was carried out by Bethany T. Nixon, Sarah C. Hamden and Timothy P. Byron.
In pop music, a "hook" is a striking melodic, rhythmic or lyrical phrase that draws attention and sticks in memory. Modern recordings consist of many layers, and the brain does not process everything equally but singles out salient moments. The researchers suggest that such phrases are held in verbal working memory - a short-term "mental notepad" that allows words and melodies to be repeated silently.
The first experiment involved 66 Australian psychology students with an average age of about 20. They listened to two of four unfamiliar songs. One was played once, the other five times; in one case participants solved simple sudoku puzzles, in the other they simply listened. Then each song was played once more without distraction, and during this pass participants moved a slider from 0 to 100, marking the moments that stood out and were easy to remember, and also rated their enjoyment of the song on a 10-point scale.
On the sixth listening, hook ratings were on average 6.76 points higher than on the second. Choruses received higher ratings than verses and other parts. The more the song was liked, the higher the ratings were: each additional point of enjoyment corresponded to an increase of 2.33 points. Contrary to expectations, the sudoku produced no significant difference. The authors suggest that sudoku mainly loads visual processing and does not directly interfere with auditory memory, or that participants made up for what they missed during the final undistracted listening.
The second experiment involved 98 students with an average age of about 21; after excluding seven people who already knew the songs, 91 remained in the analysis. Here the distraction was verbal-auditory: the researcher read out lists of 15 words, and participants recalled as many words as possible while the music played. The songs were heard once or four times. Participants then rated 20 short fragments on a 7-point scale - how much the fragment stands out and how easy it is to remember.
Listening to a song four times instead of once raised fragment ratings by an average of 0.27 points, while performing the verbal test lowered them by 0.85 points. The highest average ratings were after four listenings without distraction (4.71), the lowest after one listening with distraction (3.84). Choruses were rated higher than non-choruses by an average of 1.10 points. Musical experience played a modest role: only self-rated perception and emotional engagement showed small positive associations, explaining about 10 percent of the variance in ratings.
Even under verbal distraction, choruses retained their advantage. "If a phrase is an effective hook, it will get a fairly high rating even if a person heard it once and was distracted at the same time," co-author Timothy P. Byron explained. At the same time, ratings depended significantly on repetition and interference.
The authors caution that the sample consisted of young Australian psychology students, predominantly women, so the results may not transfer to other groups. The songs were little known, and their hooks may be inferior to chart hits. In addition, self-ratings may be mixed with simple liking for the song. The researchers plan to expand age, cultural background and genres, and also to compare self-reports with behavioral and physiological memory tests.
The work also hints at a possible way to get rid of an intrusive melody: if a song is not allowed to form a clear memory trace, it may be less likely to get "stuck". However, this is only a hypothesis requiring further testing.