When it comes to finding a romantic partner, people usually name more positive qualities than negative ones. However, there is far less agreement on which shortcomings should be avoided. A new study published in the European Journal of Social Psychology explains this paradox: desirable traits cluster tightly around a common ideal, while undesirable ones cover a much broader range of meanings.
In a series of seven experiments with a total of 1,074 participants, psychologists Tabea J. Zorn and Christian Unkelbach of the University of Cologne (Germany) studied how people generate, evaluate and use positive and negative personality traits in the context of online dating. All experiments were preregistered, and the data and materials were made openly available.
In the first three experiments, participants from the UK, the US and Germany listed the qualities they seek in a partner and the shortcomings they avoid. On average, each person named 3.61 to 4.26 positive traits versus 2.44-2.88 negative ones. At the group level, however, when the answers were combined, there were 181 unique negative words versus 152 unique positive ones. In other words, although each individual recalls more good qualities, the collective "vocabulary" of shortcomings turns out to be broader.
Then 175 participants rated 333 traits on three scales of emotional meaning: pleasantness, emotional intensity and sense of control. The researchers built a three-dimensional map and measured how close words within each category were to one another. Positive traits were more tightly clustered (average distance 1.96 on a scale from 0 to about 13.9), whereas negative ones were spread more widely (2.33). This gap persisted even after outliers were excluded.
In the next experiment, 200 people rated the importance of each trait on a 7-point scale. On average, avoiding negative qualities was judged slightly more important (5.51 points) than striving for positive ones (5.37). The most important positive traits were reliability (6.73), kindness, loyalty, sincerity and understanding; among negative ones, cruelty (6.98), infidelity, dishonesty, deceit and unreliability led. Interestingly, traits close in meaning to other members of their category were rated as more important - for both good and bad qualities, and this link was stronger for shortcomings.
Finally, in two experiments with 200 and 201 participants, hypothetical choices in a dating app were studied: participants decided whether to "swipe right" (give a chance for a date) or "left" (reject) if a partner was described with one word. For positive traits, importance predicted the decision, but closeness to other good qualities did not. For negative traits, both factors worked independently: even accounting for importance, shortcomings more closely related in meaning to other bad qualities reduced the probability of a "swipe right" more strongly. On average, 15% of participants were still willing to give a chance to a person with a shortcoming, and the share depended on the severity of the trait - from "unfashionable" to "cruel."
The authors emphasize that these are hypothetical decisions, not real behavior. In real apps, choices are strongly influenced by photos, and character traits manifest in combination. "The importance for real decisions should not be exaggerated," Unkelbach cautions. "However, the test of the model is robust." The researchers also note that it is not yet clear whether admitting a minor flaw in a profile could increase trust: in the experiments, even mild flaws reduced attractiveness.