Scientists from the University of Milan (Italy) have determined how the distribution of waking time between physical activity and sitting is related to students' well-being. A total of 2,636 people took part in the survey. The results were published in the journal Depression and Anxiety.

University students often experience psychological stress. According to estimates from a review of Italian studies, 46% of students had symptoms of depression, 65% had symptoms of anxiety, and 85% had symptoms of pronounced stress. However, data from different studies varied widely, and some of the surveys fell during the COVID-19 pandemic.

The authors of the work, Flavia Pennisi and her colleagues, sent out an anonymous online questionnaire via the university's official mailing list. Among the participants, 71% were women; 53% were aged 18-23, 32% were 24-29, and the rest were 30 or older.

The students reported their physical activity over the past week using the short version of the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ). It takes into account vigorous and moderate activity, walking and time spent sitting. The scientists classified walking as light activity. Depressive symptoms were assessed using the PHQ-9 questionnaire (a nine-item scale), general health with a single question ("How would you rate your health in general?"), and symptoms of eating disorders with the five-item SCOFF screening questionnaire.

On average, students spent 41 minutes a day on moderate-to-vigorous activity, walked for 58 minutes and sat for 321 minutes. The larger the share of time occupied by moderate-to-vigorous activity, the slightly fewer the depressive symptoms and the better the self-rated health. The more time spent sitting, the slightly more the depressive symptoms and the worse the self-rated health. Walking was not associated with these measures.

The researchers then used statistical modeling to assess how replacing one type of behavior with another is related to the outcomes. Replacing 15 minutes of sitting with moderate-to-vigorous activity was accompanied by a decrease in scores on the depression scale of approximately 0.11 (the scale runs from 0 to 27) and a slight improvement in self-rated health. A similar picture was seen when light activity was replaced with more intense activity. But exchanging time between sitting and light activity produced no noticeable differences.

With symptoms of eating disorders, the association turned out to be the opposite: more moderate-to-vigorous activity meant slightly higher scores on the SCOFF questionnaire, and more sitting meant slightly lower scores. But these associations were very weak.

"The data obtained suggest that, within the daily distribution of movement, an increase in the share of time in favor of moderate-to-vigorous activity at the expense of sitting is associated with somewhat more favorable mental and perceived health in students," the authors concluded.

It is important to understand that all the identified associations are very weak and became noticeable largely because more than 2,600 people took part in the survey. All the data are based on self-reports, so distortions due to inaccurate recall are possible. In addition, the study is cross-sectional (a single point-in-time snapshot), which means it does not allow conclusions about cause and effect. It is not excluded, for example, that students with more pronounced depressive symptoms simply move less. The scientists also did not take into account sleep, diet and socioeconomic status, and the sample is limited to a single university, which may reduce the applicability of the conclusions to other students.

Source: PsyPost