Ultraprocessed food is food that has undergone multiple industrial processing steps: for example, with added emulsifiers, flavorings and other substances not usually found in a home kitchen. A new clinical study published in the journal Nature Metabolism showed that even if such food differs almost not at all in calories, fat, sugar and fiber from less processed food, the body responds to it differently. In particular, after an ultraprocessed meal there is a significantly higher release of insulin, the hormone that regulates blood sugar levels.

The experiment involved 57 healthy adults of normal weight aged 18 to 45 (average age 26). Each of 32 participants ate both test breakfasts - ultraprocessed and minimally processed - on different days in random order. Both meals weighed about 156 grams and contained roughly 300 calories. The composition was matched so that differences in about a dozen measures, including calories, protein, fat, carbohydrates, fiber and glycemic index (how quickly a product raises blood sugar), did not exceed 1.6%. One variant had eggs, a banana, dried cranberries and cheese; the other had turkey, instant mashed potatoes, cereal, vegetable chips, cookies and a sandwich with peanut butter and jelly.

After eating, participants' blood glucose and insulin levels were measured, as well as the rate of calorie burning and the balance of carbohydrate and fat burning using a special sealed chamber. In addition, 52 people underwent brain scanning (functional MRI - a method that tracks activity in different areas via blood flow), during which they looked at photographs of foods and made monetary bids on how much they were willing to pay for them.

The results showed that overall glucose levels over three hours after both meals did not differ statistically significantly. However, after the ultraprocessed breakfast the insulin level was noticeably higher - especially at 40, 60, 90 and 120 minutes. Participants also burned more calories overall, but switched more slowly from fats to carbohydrates. In other words, the body coped worse with the usual post-meal change of "fuel."

The researchers also found that these metabolic differences were linked to brain activity in response to images of food. Participants whose switch to carbohydrate burning was more disrupted by ultraprocessed food showed higher activity in reward-related areas when viewing photographs of precisely such foods. At the same time, participants rated both types of food equally on taste and were willing to pay similar amounts for them. It is important to emphasize: this is a correlation - a statistical association that by itself does not prove that the changes in the brain are caused specifically by the metabolic shifts.

The authors note that the study was not aimed at examining long-term health consequences. In addition, it has limitations: the sample size for the brain analysis was small (29 people), and the brain response was measured not during eating but while viewing photographs on another day. It also remains unclear which specific aspects of industrial processing - additives, changes in the structure of the product or something else - lead to the observed differences. The scientists plan to continue work with different groups of people, larger portions and other products.

Source: PsyPost